Mary Todd Lincoln Group of Todds

and the

Todds of New Jersey and Pennsylvania:July 2005, rev Oct 14, Mar 2006, Aug,  Oct 2006, August 2019, May 5, 2020, June 2021

Richard K. McMurtry

 

 

Past essays about the Todds of New Jersey and Pennsylvania contained many errors which this essay intends to correct.

 

There were four groups of Todds who came to colonial New Jersey.

1.       Todds of Somerset County, New Jersey

2.       Todds of Hunterdon Co, New Jersey

3.       Mary Todd Lincoln Group of Todds (Philadelphia Co and Chester Co PA and Hunterdon Co NJ

4.       Possibly the Todds who later settled in Mecklenburg Co NC

 

 

Arrival in New Jersey and Relationships between the Various Branches

 

Somerset County Todds;    In the early days of the settlement of northwest New Jersey, came a group of five brothers, William, John, James, Andrew and Robert and an unnamed sister, who appeared in the Janeway Store records in Somerset County New Jersey as early as 1735/1736 in Peapack and Baskingridge.[i]    I assume that the Todds in Somerset County in later years  (William d 1760, Andrew d 1781 and James d 1781) are three of these brothers and that John and Robert removed from the county after 1739/41,the last date that they appeared in the Janeway Store records.  However, we don’t have birthdates for these three Todds; so it is hard to tell if they are the individuals of the Janeway Store records or the offspring of that group.   William d 1760 and Andrew Todd d 1781 appeared in Peapack, Bedminster Township, in landlord and court records as early as 1744 – and remained in the county.[ii]  James appears in records by 1755 in Bernards Township.[iii]  Based on DNA genetic analysis, William d 1760, Andrew d 1781 and James d 1781 seem to have been either brothers or close cousins to each other but not related to the Todds of Hunterdon County, nor the Mary Todd Lincoln group of Todds, nor the Mechlenburg Co NC Todds.[iv]

 

Mary Todd Lincoln Group of Todds

 

The family tradition in the Mary Todd Lincoln family was that Robert 1697-1775 and his half brother Andrew came to New York and then Robert came on “immediately” to Philadelphia Co and Andrew followed.   Tax records show Robert coming to Chester Co by 1755 and then Philadelphia County by 1760 and Andrew Todd arriving in Chester County by 1760.    Prior to Robert coming to Pennsylvania, a William Todd and John Todd baptized their children at Abingdon and First Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia Co between 1723 and 1738.      

 

Though we have found no references to the family in early New York, we do find William, John and Robert, in Bethlehem Twp, Hunterdon Co sometime after 1744.[v]  William appears in a trespass case there in 1745/1746.  John appears on a court docket in 1743[vi]; he later encumbered a debt in 1748 and was summoned to court in 1757 to pay it off.  John also was served some time between October 1754 and March 1755 with an ejectment order for land he apparently leased in Bethlehem Township.[vii]  Robert appears on a court docket in July 1743[viii] and later encumbered a debt in 1753 and been summoned to pay it in 1755.

 

Curiously, the three in Hunterdon Co, William, John and Robert, appear to have all been associated with the Abington Presbyterian Church in Philadelphia County, PA.   John and William baptized their children at Abington Church between 1723 and 1738, though they both seem to have switched churches to the First Presbyterian Church in downtown Philadelphia, 12 miles further south of Abington, during an interlude between 1729 and 1734.[ix]    Also, Robert’s son David was married in Abington in 1749 when the family was presumably living in Hunterdon County based on the court records.[x]

 

How and why William and John managed to travel the 46 miles from Bethlehem Twp to the Abingdon Church and to downtown Philadelphia to have their children baptized is a bit puzzling.   And why David Todd traveled so far to be married in 1749 in Abington is also puzzling.   We assume this had something to do with the “Great Awakening” that split Presbyterianism into factions during the 1730s.

 

After 1749, the family appears to have dispersed.  By 1750, William had moved to Augusta County, Virginia[xi]; by 1756, Robert had moved to Pikeland Township in Chester Co, PA[xii];  by 1760, David Todd and Robert Todd Jr, both sons of Robert Todd Sr had begun to get land grants in Philadelphia County[xiii]; by 1760, Andrew Todd had bought land in Chester County, PA[xiv];   We do not know the fate of John Todd, nor his relationship to Robert, Andrew and William.     However, there are several possibilities for the fate of this John.

 

We have a John Todd in the Abington church and 1st Presbyterian Church records between 1724 and 1738.   There is a John Todd in the New Jersey Supreme Court records for actions in Hunterdon Co between1754 and 1757.  There is also a John Todd in Sussex County in 1764[xv],  Lastly, we have a John Todd d 1799 who shows up in Mecklenburg Co NC by 1766 and the names of his children and relative ages are similar to those of John Todd who appears in the Philadelphia County church records.  However, in order for John to have had children at Abington  in the 1720s and died 1799, he would have to have been 99 years old when he died. Not impossible, but a bit at the outer edges of likelihood.  We do not know which if any of these four references are for the same John Todd and which are for a different John Todd.  But they could be the same person.

 

In any event, we know that John Todd d 1799 Mecklenburg Co NC was not a brother of the Mary Todd Lincoln group based on this DNA being 2 mutations different from the Mary Todd Lincoln group of Todds.

 

 

 

            John Todd of Philadelphia County, PA and John Todd of Mechlenburg

County NC

 

The John Todd who died in Mecklenburg Co NC in 1799 was probably an Irish immigrant and probably from County Derry/Londonderry where the same DNA pattern existed in Todds born in the 1780s and 1790s.

 

This family had DNA that was two mutations different from the Mary Todd Lincoln family – implying a common ancestor no less than 50 years before coming to America and possibly 100-200 years before.  So the two families were not close kin.

 

In previous years, I attempted to make the case that John Todd d 1799 of Mecklenburg Co NC was the same person as the John Todd who baptized children at the Abington Presbyterian Church beginning in 1725.    I am no longer certain of this and hold it out simply as a possibility.

 

Comparing the birth data of the first four children of John of Mecklenburg Co with the births of John Todd in the Abington and First Presbyterian Church shows a marked similarity.  The first name for the Todd birth entry for 1736 was a blank usually indicating a repeat of the name above, but on one microfilm the name John was written in.  So we are not sure if the name of this child was Alexander or John[xvi].

 

Abington Pres & 1st Pres

John Todd 1712-1799 Family History

 

 

James Todd, 2 May 1725 at Abington

James abt 1733

Elizabeth Todd, 29 Jan 1726/27 at Abington

Elizabeth abt 1731

Mary Todd, 7 Dec 1729 at First Presbyterian to John and Jane

Polly abt 1736

Alexander Todd or John Todd,  2 Oct 1736, at Abington

John abt 1738

 

William H abt 1742

 

Hugh abt 17

 

Joseph 1749

 

Hannah abt 1750

 

Adam 1751

 

If we accept that the 1736 birth was for John and not Alexander, then the first four names of the birth registers match the first four names of the family history.  We also note the 7 year gap between Mary b 1729 whose mother was Jane and John b 1736 whose mother is not identified but may be Margaret Russell identified in the family history as the wife of John Todd in Mecklenburg Co.  This would suggest that Margaret was a second marriage about 1735.

 

This linkage to Abington Presbyterian Church would require that John Todd be at least 95 years old when he died in Mecklenburg Co in 1799, assuming he was 20 years old when his first son was born.     This seems somewhat doubtful though not impossible.

 

 

            Hunterdon County NJ Todds

 

This family included:   David Todd 1730-1809, John Todd 1729-1802, and John Todd 1755-1820.    

 

David and John were reported by a grandson of David to have been brothers and to have come to America in 1749 when David was 18 years old.    David’s daughter Jane married John Todd 1755-1820 who was reported to have been from Ireland.   Since John b 1729 did not report a son John in his will, we assume that John Todd was the son of a third brother who possibly remained in Ireland. 

 

Descendants of all three of these have the same DNA pattern, but that pattern does not match the DNA pattern of the Somerset County Todds at all, and is 1 mutation from the pattern of the Mary Todd Lincoln group of Todds and the Mechlenburg Co NC Todds.

 

David b 1731 lived in Tewksbury Township which was 15 miles from Bethlehem Township, but right across the county line from Somerset County.  John b 1729 was in Hunterdon in 1780 but moved to Somerset County where he died.  John b 1755 also moved to Somerset County

 

There is also evidence for other siblings of this John 1755-1820.  There is a James Todd of the 1778 Hunterdon Co tax list may be the James Todd who bought land in Hardwick Twp, Sussex Co in 1779 and sold it in 1789 and died there in 1790 with young children.  Further there is an Elizabeth Todd who married David Wiley in 1768 and a Jane Todd who married Robert Caskey in 1777.   However, Jim Todd, a descendant of William Todd d 1760 Somerset Co NJ, reported that Jane Todd Caskey was buried in Lamington Churchyard, suggesting that this Jane was daughter of William Todd d 1760, not the Hunterdon Co Todds.   

 

            Other Lost Branches

 

There are two branches of the Todds who could be Irish immigrants or could have some connection to the other Todd families described above. These are Andrew Todd b abt 1758 d 1801 Tazewell Co VA and James Todd b abt 1750 d 1799 Augusta Co, VA.   Though I at first speculated these might be lost branches of the various families of New Jersey Todds, I am leaning towards assuming they are both Irish immigrants with common ancestor back in Ireland or Scotland.

 

Andrew Todd b abt 1758 d 1801 was a single man on tax lists in Hamilton Bann Twp in York County Pennsylvania in 1779 and 1781 and a married man in 1783.  In 1782, he married Elizabeth Sipes in Frederick Co MD and by 1787, he was living in Rockingham Co, VA.  By 1789, he was in a portion of Washington Co, VA which later became Tazewell Co where Andrew died in 1801. 

 

(There is also a Patrick Todd (on the same 1781 York Co, PA tax list as Andrew) who moved to Harford Co, MD who is considered to be a brother of Andrew (though we have not been able to trace Patrick’s descendants to get DNA samples) Andrew’s descendants DNA matches the Hunterdon Co Todds and is one mutation from the Mary Todd Lincoln group of Todds AND the Mecklenburg Co Todds.  So he could either be an Irish immigrant or a descendant of a lost branch of the Mary Todd Lincoln family or the Hunterdon Co NJ Todds. 

The Big Y male DNA test conducted in 2021 indicated that Andrew d 1801 was most closely related to the Mary Todd Lincoln Group of Todds, presumably through a descendant of a sibling or cousin of Robert Todd 1697-1775 and Andrew d 1791.

 

James Todd was in Rockingham Co, VA in 1787 (same year as Andrew appeared there) and in 1789 was in Augusta Co (Mossy Creek) where he died in 1799.  James’ birth is estimated at 1750 based on his son George being born 1770-1775.  James’ descendant STR DNA matches the Mary Todd Lincoln group of Todds.   But there is no place on their tree for this James; hence he is most likely an Irish immigrant.    A Big Y Male DNA test conducted in 2021 does not suggest a close relationship with the Mary Todd Lincoln Todds.

 

            Todds of the Janeway Store Records

 

The  five Todd brothers and an unnamed sister were listed in the Janeway Store account books in Bound Brook, Somerset County, New Jersey as early as Oct/Nov 1735 for William, John and James, the following Feb for the Andrew and Robert and in 1737 for the sister.[xvii]   William, John and Robert who lived in “Papack” (Peapack)  for certain years and James who lived in Baskenridge for certain years.  Andrew delivered goods to John and William and received goods from James, John and William; so his residence is ambiguous.

 

William and John were closely associated with each other.  For the almost two year period Oct 1735 to September 1737, they were named on a joint account at the Janeway Store.  Afterwards, from Dec 1737 to March 1743, they appeared individually except for jointly getting a bond in March 1738 and paying it off in full in December 1744. 

 

James Todd appears in the Janeway Store records in November 1735, only one month after William and John.  He last appears in July 1737.

 

Both Robert and Andrew appear a few months later than the previous three brothers – in February 1735/1736.  Neither takes out an account at the store at this time, but rather deliver goods to or receive goods from others.  Andrew continues to appear until January 1737/1738, but Robert gets his own account and records purchases in May to July 1739.

 

 

 

Bedminster Todds

 

The Todds of Bedminster Tonwship are best known for the battles of William Todd against his landlords in the 1750s.[xviii] 

           

William Todd d 1760

 

The first time they came to evict William and his family in 1753, they relented because William’s wife was still in bed after childbirth[xix].  But this was only a brief respite.  They returned and despite William and his friends and neighbors threatening violence, William and family were eventually evicted and their home demolished.  Undaunted, William was determined to return to his land.  He returned and rebuilt their home and renegotiated a lease with the landlord.  They stayed on the land til 1760 when tragedy struck again.  William died, probably only in his 40s and left a widow with few resources and a family of young children, including John b 1739, George b 1753 and William Todd b 1755 and possibly a Robert Todd born 1740s who moved to Dutchess County New York prior to 1770.[xx]    A Supreme Court case in 1762 indicated that William’s widow was still in possession of a parcel that Andrew and Lewis Johnston had transferred to a John Styles.  

 

George and William served in the Revolution and remained in the county.[xxi]  William died in 1845; George in 1830.[xxii]

 

Deeds for land of George Todd reveal that George who died in 1830 had a widow Mary Todd and a son George Todd.   George Todd also died in 1830 leaving land to his brothers Robert C. Todd and William G. Todd.    This William G. Todd married Catherine LNU and moved to Whitewater Township, Franklin County Indiana.   He sold his portion of the inherited lands to his brother Robert C. Todd for $1. He left a son William G. Todd b 1810/1814 who lived in Franklin Co IN 1850 and 1860 and in Tipton Co IN in 1870. [xxiii]

 

 Kenn Stryker-Rodda, a professional genealogist and a descendant of William Todd d 1760, believed that William’s son John was one of the “young children” mentioned in the landlord records in 1760 and hence concluded that John Todd 1755-1820 was that son.  However, DNA proves that the DNA of John Todd 1755-1820 doesn’t match the DNA pattern of William d 1760, Andrew d 1781 and James d 1781 of Somerset County.      The only other unaccounted for John Todd living in Somerset County during this period was John Todd 1739-1823.    Unlike John Todd b 1755, John b 1739 would have been old enough in 1760 when his father died to go and talk with the landlord about his mother’s situation.   Furthermore, a descendant of John b 1739 has DNA that matches the Somerset Co Todd pattern.  So I conclude that William’s son John is John Todd 1739-1823.[xxiv]

 

            John Todd md Sarah Ismay

 

John Todd 1739-1823 died in Bedminster Township, and his DNA matches another descendant of William Todd d 1760.    

 

Their children were:     Eliz 1768, Jane 1770 (md Welsh), Elanor 1771 (m James Morrow), Mary 1773 (m John Van Doren), John 1776-1857  (m Ann Phenix), Ann 1778, Rebecca 1781 md Mullen, Sarah 1782 md John Royer, Esther 1785, Lydia 1787, Robert 1789, William J. 1792-1870 md Rosannah Melick.

 

Since the Ismay family had lived in Dutchess County New York, we have assumed that the John Todd in the 1768 and 1769 tax lists of Dutchess County may have been the John Todd who was born in Somerset County, married Sarah Ismay in Duthcess County and that he returned to Somerset County after his marriage.   This further supports the theory that Robert Todd who married in 1770 in Dutchess County was a brother of John who married Sarah Ismay.   DNA from a descendant of Robert Todd of Dutchess County matches the DNA of the descendants of  John Todd and Sarah Ismay and the descendants of William Todd 1755-1845.  The Descendants of William seem to consistently have an STR DNA marker value of 29 in marker 449 whereas descendants of Andrew d 1781 and James d 1781 seem to usually have an STR DNA marker value of 28 for marker 449, i.e both of the two samples from descendants of Andrew d 1781 and two of three samples for descendants of James Todd d 1781 have a value of 28.

 

 

            Andrew Todd d 1781

 

Andrew Todd who lived only a mile away from William Todd of the landlord battles seems to have fared much better.  He negotiated leases and eventually purchased over 200 acres of land which he divided when he died in Bedminster Township in 1781 amongst his sons, Samuel and John.[xxv]

 

John b 1756 md Jane Caldwell 1779 d 1829 moved to Washington County in upstate New York in 1782. His children were:  Martha 1780, Martin Luther 1782, Stephen 1784, Betsy 1787, John 1789,Samuel 1792,James C. 1795, Archibald S. 1798, Hiram 1800, Jane 1803.  Many of his descendants later migrated to SW Pennsylvania and Ohio and John followed them there in his old age just before he died.[xxvi]

 

Samuel b abt 1758 d 1816 (check date).  His children according to his will were: Nancy, Daniel, Samuel, Andrew, John F., James S., Jos W.  Daniel Todd was in Somerset as late as 1840.  Descendants of this family have not been traced, except that one research believes that Samuel’s son Samuel was the Samuel Todd 1793-1849 who married in Yates County New York in 1831 to Susannah Wilbur and had children:  William Samuel Todd 1831 Yates Co – 1908 Orleans Co NY,  Susan Todd 1833, Andrew Stinson Todd 1836, George A Todd 1837, John Alrah Todd 1838-1892, Nancy Todd 1843.

 

 

Bernards Township Todds

 

The only Todd who lived in Bernards Township was James Todd died 1781.  

 

I have assumed that he is the same person as the James Todd who lived in Baskingridge in 1735-37 as documented in the Janeway store records.   However, we are unable to precisely define the birthdates of his children and hence have difficulty inferring whether James was old enough to have been shopping in the Janeway store in 1735.

 

The only other old record we have for James appears in Somerset County on a road survey record in 1755.[xxvii]      His will in Bernards Township in 1781 lists his wife Jemima (who died in 1809) and the following children:  James, Joseph, John, David,Robert, Mary (md MacTire), Ann, Elenor, Dau? (m Alan Cameron?).

 

Later deed and mortage records in the 1780s show that the family lived near Greater Crossroads adjacent to the Dead River.[xxviii]   These records also indicate that James’ son John married Sarah Kirkpatrick.  David is reported elsewhere to have died in 1799 and having married Mary McCollum. Robert appears in the tax lists in Somerset County in the 1790s thereby establishing that the Robert Todd b 1740s who married in Dutchess Co NY was not the son of James Todd d 1781..[xxix]

 

Son John seems to have had a son James b 1782 who married in 1805 in Baskingridge Presbyterian Church to Betsy/Elizabeth Anderson and went to Tompkins County, New York prior to 1810.[xxx]   James and Elizabeth had a son James Kirkpatrick Todd which makes us think that James b 1782 was the son of John and Sarah Kirkpatrick.

 

 

 

 

Conclusion

 

This essay has sorted out the origins and relationships between the many lines of Todds of colonial Somerset and Hunterdon County.  It has also listed the second generation so that researchers trying to connect their New Jersey origin Todds can see the possible points of connection to the larger family tree.  It has also pointed to branches that stayed in New Jersey and branches that left New Jersey which have not been traced down and which are a fertile ground of research for Todd family historians. 

 

Acknowledgements

 

I would like to acknowledge the Todd historians that have gone before us and paved the way for this research: 

 

Rev. Isaac Todd 1796-1885, descendant of David Todd 1731-1809

George W. Todd, descendant of David Todd 1731-1809

Emily Todd Helm, descendant of Robert Todd 1697-1775

Dr. Seymour Simeon Todd, descendant of Robert Todd 1697-1775

Arthur McFarland, descendant of Robert Todd 1697-1775

Carrie McLaughlin, descendant of John Todd 1755-1820

John Emmett Todd, 1853-1901,  descendant of John Todd 1755-1820

Deanne Moreau Jackman, descendant of Andrew Todd d 1781

Kenn Stryker Rodda, descendant of William Todd d 1760

Bruce Baker, desc of John Todd 1712-1799 Mecklenburg Co, NC.

 

Also, to all those current researchers and DNA donors: Carol Langford, George J. Todd, Adair Shephard, Kay Newland (Kotch), John Stratton Todd, Richard Todd, Grantland Todd, Constance Christie, Morris Todd, Stephen Thompson, Olive Todd (Mrs George W Todd), Kathryn Gardner, G Peter Todd, Miles Todd, Dorothy Strafford.  Also to “anonymous” Todd who doesn’t like me to use his name because he disagrees with my conclusions and methods but who has been of immense assistance in providing me with the information that served as a point of departure in the research leading to the results of this essay.

 



[i] In February 1735, “John and William Todd” delivered goods to “their brother Andrew” (page 579) and in Mar 1735, James Todd also delivered goods to “his brother Andrew” (page 595).  In July 1739, William Todd delivered goods to “his brother Robert” (page 133);  In March 1737, John Todd delivered goods to his sister (page 763).  “William Todd of Papack” is listed on the account ledger from Oct 1738 to April 1 1742 and possibly October 1743 or 1744 (page 2);  John Todd of Papack” is listed on the account ledger from Feb 1737 (i.e. 1737/1738) to April 1741. (p 29); “James Todd at Baskenridge” is on the account ledger  in June and August 1738 (p 77); “ Robert Todd,  brother to Wm of Papack” is listed on the account ledger from July and August 1739 (page 150) and in a journal entry for Feb 1735/36  (page 585).  Janeway Store Records, Rutgers University Library, New Brunswick, NJ.

[ii] Andrew Johnston Journals, Somerset Quarterly Magazine of History and Genealogy, ____

[iii] James appears in a Somerset County Road record about 1755 (need to check this); John Todd who married Sarah Ismay appeared at a later date.  The DNA of John and James is similar which identifies them as brothers. 

[iv] The DNA indicates that the Andrew and William had 1 mutation between them, and John Todd 1739-1823 has the same mutation as William.  This suggests that William had the mutation and John b 1739 was his son.   However, a descendant of James d 1781 has this same mutation; so a second sample of a second lineage of James d 1781 is needed to confirm that James had the same value for that DNA marker as Andrew d 1781.    DNA shows a dozen mutations or so from the other New Jersey Todds; so they are not related.    DNA samples from Robert Todd, son of James d 1781 are essential to confirm this interpretation of the data.

[v] John McQuire vs William Todd, New Jersey Supreme Court Case, 27139, 1745/1746, New Jersey State Archives: “To the Sheriff of our county of Hunterdon, we command you to take William Todd otherwise ___ Todd of ye Township of Bethleham in thee County of Hunterdon …if he may be found within your Bailywick..safely keep so that we may have his body before us at our City of Burlington on the first Tuesday in November next to Answer John Magguire of a plea of Trespass and also to the bill of him the sd John aginst him the said William for twenty on pounds currency Lawful money of New Jersey of Debt according to the Custom of our ___before us then and there to exhibited and have you..Robert…Morris Esq our Chierf Justice at City of Perth Amboy, this twentieth day of august in the nineteenth year of our Reign”; 

Benjamin Armitage vs John Todd, Case 1751, May Term 1757, Hunterdon County New Jersey Inferior Court of Common Pleas: “May term..1757..John Todd otherwise called John Todd of Bethelhem Township in the county of Hunterdon in the province of New West Jersey, cooper was summoned to answer Benjamin Armitage of a Plea that he render unto him the sum of 19 pounds 17 shillings and 6 pence lawfull money of Pensilvania which to ..he owes and from him unjustly detains and whereupon the said Benjamin Armitage by William Pidgeon his attorney saith that whereas the aforesaid John Todd the Eleventh day of May in the Year of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and forty eight at Trenton in the county of Hunterdon and within the Jurisdiction of this court by his certain writing obligatory did grant him self to be held and firmly bound unto the said Benjamin in the said sum of 19 pounds 17 shillings and 6 pence money aforesaid to be paid to the said Benjamin when he the said John Todd should be thereunto required Nevertheless the aforesaid john Todd hath often required..the aforesaid 19 pound 17 shillings and 6 pence unto him the said Benjamin Armitage hat no t as yet paid the same o time as yet to pay he the said John Todd hitherto altogether hath refused and still doth refuse to the damage of him the said Benjamin Armitage Ten Pounds proclamation money and thereof he brings this suit.. and brings here into Court the writing obligatory aforesaid which the debt aforesaid in form aforesaid. Witnesseth the date whereof is the same day and year aforesaid.  …John Todd of Bethlehem township in the said county cooper..Benjamin Armitage of Bristol township in the county of Philadelphia in Pensylvania yeoman …

Peter Kembel vs Robert Todd, Case 1321, February Term 1755, Hunterdon County New Jersey Inferior Court of Common Pleas: “February term 1755..Robert  Todd otherwise called Robert Todd of Bethlehem Township in the county of Hunterdon and Province of New Jersey was summoned to answer of Peter Kemble of a plea of that he render unto him the sum of eight pounds one shilling and two pence ..whereas the said Robert the … day of April 1753 at Trenton..writing obligatory acknowledged himself to be bound unto the..Peter……Peter Kembel puts into his place Courtland Skinner his attorney…

[vi] Hunterdon County Court Docket, July 1738

[vii] New Jersey Supreme Court Case 20116, “Andrew Johnston, John Stevens and James Parker the tenth day of October “(1754) “at Bethlehem in the county of Hunterdon” sued a fictitous person referred to as “Richard Fen” for illegally possessing “500 acres of arable land, 500 acres of pasture land, 500 acres of woodland and 500 acres of Meadowland” “situate .. in Bethlehem”.  This fictitious person then wrote to “Mr John Todd…You may perceive by the above declaration in Ejectment that I am sued for the premises therein mentioned all or part of which you are in possession of and to which I have no title, Therefore if you have any thereto and intend to Defend it, you must appear at the next Supreme Court to be held at the City of Burlington on the Second Tuesday in May next by some attorney of that court and cause yourself to be made Defendant in my stead. Otherwise I shall suffer judgement to be entered against me by default and you will be turned out of possession, I am…your loving friend Richard Fenn”. 

[viii] Hunterdon County Court Docket, August 1743

[ix] Abington Presbyterian Church baptisms and marriage records, LDS microfilm #______

[x] Early Pennsylvania Marriages, source??

[xi] Deed Records of Augusta County per Lyman Chalkley, Chronicles of the Scotch-Irish Settlement in Virginia, ______.  We know that William of Augusta County is the William of Abington Church because William’s son Low Todd was baptized in that church in 1723 and Low Todd also buys land in Augusta in 1750.  There are no other Low Todds who appear in any records in this era in other locations.

[xii] Index to Chester County tax lists prepared by Gilbert Cope, in custody of Chester County Archives

[xiii]     Land Warrants of Philadelphia County:

David Todd,accept ,150acres,13 Nov 1760, 15 Nov 1760, 150 acres, David Todd, AA1,p145,Survey,A76,p223

Robert Todd, Jr, accept, 200 acres, 19 Dec 1760, 22Dec 1760, 200 acres, Robert Todd, AA2, p 142

David Todd, accept,44.56 acres, 7 mar 1765, 26 Apr 1765,44.56, David Todd, AA6,p228, A76 195

David Todd, accept, 134.115 acres, 13 Dec 1769, 21 Nov 1769, 134.115 acres David Todd, A11, p181

[xiv] Deed Records of Chester County, PA (need to dig out the book and page number)

[xv] Sussex County history by ___, page)

[xvi] Alexander Todd that appears in later Pennsylvania records appears to be related to the Todds of Gloucester Co NJ.  There is a record of Alexander Todd in Hunterdon records in 1765 and 1767[xvi] and in the New Jersey Supreme Court Records in 1789-1790[xvi].  Hunterdon County Inferior Court of Common Pleas, Case 3496, 20131: Alexander Todd and Charles Willing charged Wm Hawlings with non-payment of debt from 23 April 1765 in court of Feb 1767.  Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Samuel (Ex.), Case 41530, 1789; Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Edward, Case 41531, 1790; Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Elizabeth, Case 41532, 1790; The Samuel Sharp case had to do with Samuel executor of the estate of Samuel’s father Anthony Sharp of Gloucester Co. who owed Alexander money.

The Supreme Court record is in relation to the Sharp family into which an Alexander Todd married a Polly Sharp in 1770.   Alexander was in business dealings with Polly’s father in Sussex Co NJ.

Alexander appears on a Philadelphia tax list in 1769 and had a son William Hepburn Todd who married in Philadelphia in 1795.

Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Samuel (Ex.), Case 41530, 1789; Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Edward, Case 41531, 1790; Todd, Alex vs Sharp, Elizabeth, Case 41532, 1790; The Samuel Sharp case had to do with Samuel executor of the estate of Samuel’s father Anthony Sharp of Gloucester Co. who owed Alexander money.

 

[xvii]   Janeway Store records are contained in microfilm in the Special Collections Dept of Rutgers University Library.   A published index is available also.

 

[xviii] The story of William Todd and his battles with the landlord are in two places:  The Somerset County Historical Quarterly (get exact title, date, volume, pages); a manuscript of Kenn Stryker-Rodda in the possession of the Somerset County Genealogical Society which includes excerpts from a court case involving William Todd.

[xix] The childbirth story is in the Styker-Rodda manuscript.

[xx] The Johnston Journals mention John Todd as son of William Todd.  Kenn Stryker-Rodda manuscript gives a rationale for George and William also being sons of William Todd.   He gives John’s birth as 1755 which misled me to think that this was John Todd 1755-1820, but DNA shows that John Todd 1755-1820 was from Hunterdon County NJ group of Todds and not the Somerset County NJ Todds.  

[xxi] William or George has a revolutionary war pension application that makes reference to the other brother.

[xxii] William’s gravestone says died 1845 age 90 per Somerset County Historical Quarterly (check title).

[xxiii] Sept 8, 1831: Release of Dower Catharine Todd wife of William G. Todd:  Whereas George Todd, late of the Township of Bedminster did by his last will..8 June 1830..dispose of all his real Estate lying and being in the aforesaid township of Bedminster..1/3 part ..to his widow Mary Todd during her widowhood..the remaining 2/3 the use of to his son George and after the death of his said widow Mary Todd the remaining one third also to his son George all during life and at his death incase he leaves no lawful ..sire then the said real estate to descend and be equally divided between his surviving brothers and whereas George Todd (the son) after the death of his father (the Testator) .entered in the possession and enjoyment of the Estate. and whereas George Todd (the son) departed this life in the month of October last past leaving no lawful issue and whereas by virtue of the will of George Todd (the father( aforesaid the two brothers via William G. Todd and Robert C. Todd surviving their brother George have entered into the possession of the real Estate..and whereas the said William G. Todd did on. 27 Nov 1830 sell unto his brother Robert C. Todd..all his equal undivided half part of all that farm and plantation owned and held by them..

William G. Todd at the time of conveyance did reside in the state of New Jersey ..being a married man and whose wife resides in the state of Indiana(named Catharine Todd)..I Catharine Todd of the Township of Whitewater and County of Franklin and State of Indiana..wife of aforesaid William G. Todd.  for $1..quitclaim interest to Robert C. Todd.

[xxiv] Morris Todd of New York state has done considerable research on the Washington County Todds.  This work is included in the 2004 Todd Families in America Collection.  Deane Moreau Jackman has also published a history of the John Todd 1756-1829 family though he erroneously confuses Samuel and John Todd of Somerset County with the John Todd and Samuel Todd of Bedford County PA.

[xxv] Will of Andrew Todd, 1781, Somerset County NJ (get reference and abstract)

[xxvi] Ibid

[xxvii] Somerset County Road Book (need volume, page,date)

[xxviii] Need to get deed references

[xxix] Sharilyn Whitaker has researched this family or knows of folks who have.

[xxx] Kathryn Gardner has researched this family.